What should a good interview process look like?
We all know you can't please everybody. But how do you avoid having to repeat the process in 3 months?
It's easier to find the right talent if you know what you're looking for
"We hired someone like this last year didn't we? Let's not reinvent the wheel."
Well, the person you hired last year was when your business was focusing on something different. And time invested in getting this right pays dividends. What is the problem you're trying to solve? Is it targeting a new vertical? Is it taking on leadership of a team that's underperforming? Is it that you've got too many leads and need someone that can convert them into paying clients? Start with the problem you're trying to solve and describe the person that can solve that problem. Hint: it matters less whether that person has 7 years of sales experience vs 4 than it does that they can demonstrate a familiarity with selling the kind of thing you sell to the kind of people you sell it to. Challenge yourself on what they need to know now vs what they can be taught. You can train someone on how your product works. You can't as easily train them to be natural with clients and a positive addition to the workforce.
Keep the stages finite and constructive
Sarah the CTO should speak to your potential new CRO. But if she's based in San Francisco you'd be well-advised to find a time that works for everyone in the U.K and group it together with other interested parties rather than make it a sixth round.
And while she may be speaking to a new Account Exec once in a while, there's no need for her to be involved in that process - they can meet as and when. With more junior hires they need to speak to their potential line manager a couple of times, a second key pair of eyes and then offer the opportunity for them to speak to someone in the existing team on a less formal basis. We all know that "everything's an interview" but it doesn't have to feel that way. Candidates appreciate thorough, well-planned processes rather than the situations I hear about every week of "I'm in round 5 - God knows how many more stages are left".
Put a realistic time frame on the process at the outset
As much as this serves candidates who like the certainty so they can balance other opportunities against it and can plan accordingly, it helps you as a hiring team not lose candidates due to interminable opaque processes. This happens regularly - every prospect I speak to believes their need to hire is urgent. It rarely is. Urgent is: we're prepared to interview someone today and know exactly what we're looking for and here are some slots that I'd like you to fill with candidates. Urgent is not "just waiting to align with some key figures in another office".
Be decisive
Two common mistakes hiring companies make after having interviewed late stage candidates. 1) "Not sure about them but we'll keep them as a reserve option". If you're thinking this, you haven't found the right person and you should reassess your hiring process as you're wasting your time and the candidate's. 2) "We all really liked the candidate, but we just want to see if there's someone better". Spoiler alert: there's always someone better. In 2012 I proposed to my then girlfriend. She assessed her options and decided that pragmatically I fitted the brief well enough to take me on as a husband. Now there are clearly husbands with smaller heads with more impressive pedigrees (having recently discussed my family tree with my Dad he summed it up as "we came from nothing the Skeltons and we've been moving sideways ever since") but she knew what she was looking for and I was the best candidate she'd seen. Had she decided to wait to see if there were better options available she may indeed have found one, but she would have missed out on 16 years of helpful comments, amusing quips and some lovely singing.
For more advice if you're hiring, feel free to drop me a line.
Have a great weekend - series 2 of The Payments Interviews kicks off next week with Angus Burrell who is almost guaranteed to be wearing a lively shirt.
Hiring, or thinking about a move?
Book a call